Your Best Employees Are Already Teaching You — You Just Haven’t Been Listening
The Email Audit Idea
Rob described a firm they were considering hiring whose approach was: go through the email history of every property manager and look for patterns. Which ones are getting better outcomes? What are they actually writing when a security deposit dispute comes up? How do they respond when a landlord pushes back on a maintenance bill? What language, what tone, what structure — and how does it differ between someone who consistently resolves situations well and someone who doesn’t?
This is something that would have been essentially impossible to do at scale without AI. You can’t manually read thousands of emails, tag them by outcome, and extract patterns in any reasonable time frame. But AI can. Feed it the communication history, define what good outcomes look like, and ask it to find the signal in the noise.
The result isn’t just interesting analysis. It’s a playbook.
Building the Repository
Once you’ve identified what the best responses look like, you build a repository.
Not a static document that lives in a shared drive and gets ignored. A living, searchable resource — ideally connected directly to the tools your team uses every day — that can surface the right response framework at the right moment. A property manager dealing with a security deposit dispute can pull up the approaches that have historically led to the best outcomes and model their response accordingly. A newer team member handling their first maintenance billing complaint has a guide built from real examples, not generic scripts.
Why This Matters Beyond Property Management
The core idea here applies to any business where communication drives outcomes: sales teams, customer service operations, investor relations, tenant management, contractor coordination. If you have a body of communication history and some way of measuring which interactions led to good results, you have the raw material for this kind of analysis.
The firms that figure this out first aren’t just going to be more efficient — they’re going to onboard faster, perform more consistently, and retain clients longer. The best practices that used to live only with your most experienced people become accessible to everyone.
Your top performers have already written the playbook. AI can finally help you read it.
Rob Coldwell and TJ Hock are the owners of Rentwell Property Management. They were the featured speakers at the April meeting of DIG Philly in King of Prussia. Hear their full presentation and many more on our podcast “Living Well with Rentwell”.
Subscribe today on Apple, Spotify, and Youtube!
For more information on property management in the East Falls area, schedule a free owners’ consultation at Rentwell.com
